Skip to content
GizmoDriver

Cadillac XT5 vs Toyota RAV4 Prime (2024)

Price gap, MSRP + destination

$205

Car 1

Car 2

XT5RAV4 PrimeMSRP + destination$45,290$45,085Horsepower235 hp302 hpTorque258 lb-ft165 lb-ftMPG combined24 mpg38 mpgCargo, seats up30.0 cu ft33.5 cu ftRear legroom39.0 in37.8 inFront legroom41.2 in41.0 inTowing1,000 lb2,500 lbSeats550-60 mph7.2 s5.7 s
Scored measures. Each is scaled to the larger value. Bold: the winner.
XT5 Luxury FWD vs RAV4 Prime SE AWD
MeasureXT5RAV4 PrimeWinner
MSRP + destination$45,290$45,085About the same
Horsepower235 hp302 hpRAV4 Prime
Torque258 lb-ft165 lb-ftXT5
MPG combined24 mpg38 mpgRAV4 Prime
EV rangeN/A42 miN/A
Cargo, max63.0 cu ft63.2 cu ft to 69.8 cu ftN/A
Cargo, seats up30.0 cu ft33.5 cu ftRAV4 Prime
Rear legroom39.0 in37.8 inXT5
Front legroom41.2 in41.0 inAbout the same
Length189.6 in180.9 inNot scored
Width74.9 in73.0 inNot scored
Curb weight3,915 lb4,235 lbNot scored
Towing1,000 lb2,500 lbRAV4 Prime
Seats55About the same
Ground clearanceN/A8.0 inN/A
0-60 mph7.2 s estimate5.7 s estimateRAV4 Prime
Basic warranty4 yr / 50,000 mi3 yr / 36,000 miXT5

Not scored: length, width, curb weight. N/A rows are not counted.

Nearest trims by price

Each trim and the rival trim nearest in MSRP
TrimNearest in priceGap
XT5 Luxury FWD
$43,895
RAV4 Prime SE AWD
$43,690
$205
RAV4 Prime SE AWD
$43,690
XT5 Luxury FWD
$43,895
$205

Cost to run

RAV4 Prime costs $4,570 less over 6 years.

12,000 miles a year. Gas $3.20. Electricity 17 cents per kWh. Plug-in share 50%.

Price plus fuel or charging over 6 years
CostXT5RAV4 Prime
MSRP + destination$45,290$45,085
Fuel or charging, 1 year$1,600$872
Fuel or charging, 6 years$9,600$5,235
Total, 6 years$54,890$50,320

Which is better for me?

Weight each group from 0 to 10. MPG uses fuel or charging cost.

Equal weights: RAV4 Prime wins.

No single weight change flips the winner.

Who is ahead in each group
GroupAheadBy
PriceAbout the same
MPGRAV4 Prime45%
PowerRAV4 Prime22%
SpaceN/A
TowingRAV4 Prime60%

Other years

What this cannot tell you

Your price and mpg will differ.

Reliability and safety are not included.

How values are checked