Skip to content
GizmoDriver

BMW X2 vs Cadillac XT5 (2026)

Price gap, MSRP + destination

$545

Car 1

Car 2

X2XT5MSRP + destination$46,050$46,595Horsepower241 hp235 hpTorque295 lb-ft258 lb-ftMPG combined28 mpg24 mpgCargo, max51.7 cu ft63.0 cu ftCargo, seats up25.3 cu ft30.0 cu ftFront legroom40.3 in41.2 inTowing3,968 lb1,000 lbSeats550-60 mph6.2 s7.2 s
Scored measures. Each is scaled to the larger value. Bold: the winner.
X2 xDrive28i AWD vs XT5 Luxury FWD
MeasureX2XT5Winner
MSRP + destination$46,050$46,595About the same
Horsepower241 hp235 hpX2
Torque295 lb-ft258 lb-ftX2
MPG combined28 mpg24 mpgX2
Cargo, max51.7 cu ft63.0 cu ftXT5
Cargo, seats up25.3 cu ft30.0 cu ftXT5
Rear legroomN/A39.0 inN/A
Front legroom40.3 in41.2 inXT5
Length179.3 in189.6 inNot scored
Width72.6 in74.8 inNot scored
Curb weight3,803 lb3,915 lbNot scored
Towing3,968 lb1,000 lbX2
Seats55About the same
Ground clearance8.1 inN/AN/A
0-60 mph6.2 s tested7.2 s estimateX2
Basic warranty4 yr / 50,000 mi4 yr / 50,000 miAbout the same

Not scored: length, width, curb weight. N/A rows are not counted.

Nearest trims by price

Each trim and the rival trim nearest in MSRP
TrimNearest in priceGap
X2 xDrive28i AWD
$44,700
XT5 Luxury FWD
$44,800
$100
XT5 Luxury FWD
$44,800
X2 xDrive28i AWD
$44,700
$100

Cost to run

X2 costs $1,916 less over 6 years.

12,000 miles a year. Gas $3.20. Electricity 17 cents per kWh.

Price plus fuel or charging over 6 years
CostX2XT5
MSRP + destination$46,050$46,595
Fuel or charging, 1 year$1,371$1,600
Fuel or charging, 6 years$8,229$9,600
Total, 6 years$54,279$56,195

Which is better for me?

Weight each group from 0 to 10. MPG uses fuel or charging cost.

Equal weights: X2 wins.

XT5 wins if Towing weight is 0 or less.

Who is ahead in each group
GroupAheadBy
PriceAbout the same
MPGX214%
PowerX22%
SpaceXT518%
TowingX275%

Other years

What this cannot tell you

Your price and mpg will differ.

Reliability and safety are not included.

How values are checked