Skip to content
GizmoDriver

Price and payments

Should I repair my car or replace it?

Repair bill vs the cost of a newer car.

Gap at 24 months

$13,958

  • Repair.
  • Repair: $248 a month. Replace: $830 a month.
  • Replacing saves $16 a month on fuel.
  • Repair stays cheaper for 10 years.

Current car

Replacement car

12,000 miles a year. Gas $3.20. Electricity 17 cents a kWh. 7.0% APR. 60 months. 6% sales tax on the price.

$0$5.0k$10.0k$15.0k$20.0k$25.0k$30.0k0 mo6 mo12 mo18 mo24 mo30 mo36 moRepairReplace
Total cash cost by month. Blue: repair. Orange: replace.
Cost a month, averaged over each period
PeriodRepair a monthReplace a monthGap in totalCheaper
12 months$373$960$7,039Repair
24 months$248$830$13,958Repair
36 months$206$786$20,877Repair
Fuel now
$123 a month
Fuel, new car
$107 a month
New car price
$31,195
Loan
$593 a month, 60 months

What this cannot tell you

Cash cost only. The new car's resale value is not counted.

Future repairs on the old car are not counted.

  • 2 or more sources
  • 1 source
  • Model-level, rule or estimate

How values are checked

Price and payments: more tools