Is the 2024 Land Rover Defender a good car?
No.
3 of 7checks
- Family car: 2 of 4. Rear legroom 36.6 in. Class median 38.6 in.
- First car: 2 of 5. Price $56,400. Class median $47,450.
- Commuter: $146 a month. Class median $111.
- Good buy: 23 rivals beat it on all four.
20 miles one way, 5 days a week. Gas $3.20. Power 17 cents per kWh.
| Check | Result | Number |
|---|---|---|
| Family car | No | 2 of 4 parts |
| First car | No | 2 of 5 parts |
| Commuter | No | $146 vs $111 a month |
| Seniors | Yes | 2 of 3 parts |
| Off-road | Yes | 9.0 in, top 20% |
| Worth the money | Yes | 4% below predicted |
| Good buy | No | 23 beat it on all four |
- Each check compares the cheapest trim with the number to its class.
- A check passes when it misses at most 1 part.
- Yes when the car passes more than half of its checks.
Is the Defender a good family car?
No. Passes 2 of 4 parts.
| Measure | This car | Class | Cars | Pass |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seats | 5 seats | 5 or more | N/A | Yes |
| Rear legroom | 36.6 in | Median 38.6 in | 172 | No |
| Rear headroom | 40.4 in | Median 38.7 in | 174 | Yes |
| Cargo behind the last row | 10.5 cu ft | Median 25.3 cu ft | 182 | No |
Is the Defender a good first car?
No. Passes 2 of 5 parts.
| Measure | This car | Class | Cars | Pass |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $56,400 | Median $47,450 | 187 | No |
| Horsepower | 296 hp | 169 hp to 355 hp | 188 | Yes |
| Length | 197.5 in | Median 190.5 in | 180 | No |
| Turning circle | 38.0 ft | Median 38.7 ft | 169 | Yes |
| Fuel cost per mile | 16.8 cents | Median 12.8 cents | 189 | No |
Horsepower: 10th to 75th percentile of the class.
Is the Defender a good commuter car?
No. $146 a month to commute. Class median $111.
- Miles a month
- 867
- This car
- $146
- Median of 189 SUVs
- $111
- Highway mpg
- 21 mpg, top 81% of 155
Is the Defender a good car for seniors?
Yes. Passes 2 of 3 parts.
| Measure | This car | Class | Cars | Pass |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step-in height | 8.9 in clearance, 77.7 in tall | 7.0 to 8.3 in clearance, 64.6 to 69.9 in tall | 164 | No |
| Front headroom | 40.6 in | Median 39.9 in | 172 | Yes |
| Turning circle | 38.0 ft | Median 38.7 ft | 169 | Yes |
Step-in: clearance and height in the middle half of the class.
Is the Defender a good off-road vehicle?
Yes. 9.0 in clearance. Top 20% of 175 trucks and SUVs.
- AWD or 4WD
- Yes
- Best trim for clearance
- 110 X-Dynamic SE AWD, 9.0 in
- Cohort
- 175 trucks and SUVs, AWD or 4WD trims
Is the Defender worth the money?
Yes. Priced 4% below cars like it.
- Price, 110 S AWD
- $60,450
- Predicted price
- $63,221
- Gap
- -$2,771 (-4%)
- Model error
- 14% median, 310 cars
Price model: horsepower, length, width, drivetrain, powertrain, body and luxury, 2024 cars.
Passes at up to 5% above the predicted price.
Is the Defender a good buy?
No. 23 rivals cost less and beat it on fuel cost, cargo and power.
Cheapest 8 shown.
| Car | Price | Fuel cost per mile | Max cargo | Power |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Defender 90 P300 S AWD | $56,400 | 16.8 cents | 44.6 cu ft | 296 hp |
| Chevrolet Traverse Limited LS FWD | $34,520 | 15.2 cents | 97.6 cu ft | 305 hp |
| Ford Explorer RWD | $36,860 | 13.3 cents | 87.8 cu ft | 300 hp |
| GMC Acadia Elevation FWD | $42,600 | 13.9 cents | 97.5 cu ft | 328 hp |
| Chevrolet Blazer RS FWD | $42,800 | 14.5 cents | 64.2 cu ft | 308 hp |
| Nissan Ariya Engage e-4ORCE AWD | $43,590 | 6.0 cents | 59.7 cu ft | 335 hp |
| Buick Enclave Essence FWD | $43,900 | 15.2 cents | 97.4 cu ft | 310 hp |
| Genesis GV70 2.5T Standard AWD | $44,900 | 13.3 cents | 56.9 cu ft | 300 hp |
| VinFast VF8 Eco AWD | $46,000 | 6.6 cents | 48.4 cu ft | 349 hp |
Compared with 1,150 trims of other makes, SUVs, 2024.
What this cannot tell you
No safety, reliability or insurance data.
Your prices, use and trim may differ.
- 2 or more sources
- 1 source
- Model-level, rule or estimate
- Sources disagree