Skip to content
GizmoDriver

Mazda MX-5 vs Mercedes-Benz SL-Class (2024)

Price gap, MSRP

$82,815

Car 1

Car 2

MX-5SL-ClassMSRP$28,985$111,800Horsepower181 hp375 hpMPG combined29 mpg22 mpgCargo, max4.6 cu ft13.5 cu ftFront legroom43.1 in42.9 inSeats24Ground clearance4.9 in3.8 in0-60 mph6.0 s5.1 s
Scored measures. Each is scaled to the larger value. Bold: the winner.
MX-5 Miata Sport RWD vs SL-Class SL-Class AMG SL 43 RWD
MeasureMX-5SL-ClassWinner
MSRP$28,985$111,800MX-5
Horsepower181 hp375 hpSL-Class
Torque151 lb-ftN/AN/A
MPG combined29 mpg22 mpgMX-5
Cargo, max4.6 cu ft13.5 cu ftSL-Class
Front legroom43.1 in42.9 inAbout the same
Length154.1 in181.6 inNot scored
Width68.1 inN/AN/A
Curb weight2,368 lb4,035 lbNot scored
Seats24SL-Class
Ground clearance4.9 in3.8 inMX-5
0-60 mph6.0 s estimate5.1 s estimateSL-Class
Basic warranty3 yr / 36,000 mi4 yr / 50,000 miSL-Class

Not scored: length, width, curb weight. N/A rows are not counted.

Nearest trims by price

Each trim and the rival trim nearest in MSRP
TrimNearest in priceGap
MX-5 Miata Sport RWD
$28,985
SL-Class SL-Class AMG SL 43 RWD
$111,800
$82,815
SL-Class SL-Class AMG SL 43 RWD
$111,800
MX-5 MX-5 Miata RF Club RWD
$40,210
$71,590

Cost to run

MX-5 costs $85,343 less over 6 years.

12,000 miles a year. Gas $3.20. Electricity 17 cents per kWh.

Price plus fuel or charging over 6 years
CostMX-5SL-Class
MSRP$28,985$111,800
Fuel or charging, 1 year$1,324$1,745
Fuel or charging, 6 years$7,945$10,473
Total, 6 years$36,930$122,273

Which is better for me?

Weight each group from 0 to 10. MPG uses fuel or charging cost.

Equal weights: SL-Class wins.

MX-5 wins if Price weight is 7 or more.

Who is ahead in each group
GroupAheadBy
PriceMX-574%
MPGMX-524%
PowerSL-Class52%
SpaceSL-Class66%
TowingN/A

Other years

What this cannot tell you

Your price and mpg will differ.

Reliability and safety are not included.

How values are checked